When it comes to selling indie games, two platforms often dominate the conversation: Steam and Itch.io. Both have advantages and cater to different types of developers and games. But how do you choose between them? Here’s a comparison of Steam and Itch.io to help indie developers decide where to sell their games.
1. Audience Size
Steam is by far the larger platform, boasting millions of active users every day. The sheer number of potential buyers on Steam makes it an ideal platform for developers who are looking to reach a massive audience. However, with great exposure comes fierce competition. Indie games on Steam often struggle to stand out unless they receive significant marketing efforts or positive user reviews. In contrast, Itch.io is a smaller, niche platform, but it allows for more personal connections with a dedicated community.
2. Revenue Share
One of the most significant differences between Steam and Itch.io is their revenue-sharing models. Steam typically takes a 30% cut of each sale, which is standard in the industry. However, Itch.io offers more flexibility, with developers able to set their own revenue share percentage (the platform suggests a 10% cut). This can be a huge advantage for smaller developers who need to keep as much revenue as possible.
3. Freedom and Control
Itch.io gives developers more freedom over how they want to sell their games. Developers can set prices, offer pay-what-you-want options, and even distribute their games for free. Itch.io’s user-friendly interface allows for easy updates and custom branding for individual game pages. Steam, on the other hand, has more restrictions, such as mandatory content approval processes and more rigid store policies.
4. Community and Visibility
Steam offers a massive user base, but it’s also flooded with thousands of games, making it difficult for indie developers to gain visibility without significant marketing efforts or hitting the “lucky” algorithm. Itch.io, while smaller, has a tight-knit community of indie game enthusiasts who actively support and discover new games. Developers have more opportunities to connect with players and receive feedback directly.
5. Game Types
Itch.io is a great platform for experimental, niche, or less polished games that might not fit Steam’s more commercialized approach. Steam tends to cater more to polished, completed games, especially those with large-scale marketing budgets behind them. If your game is quirky, experimental, or in an early access state, Itch.io may be the better choice.
In conclusion, the choice between Steam and Itch.io depends on your goals. If you’re looking for mass exposure and are willing to navigate the competitive environment, Steam is the way to go. However, if you prefer more creative freedom and a supportive indie community, Itch.io offers a more flexible and personal platform for your game.
Leave a Reply